Discussion about this post

User's avatar
AnnaMarie's avatar

I really like this angry story, especially the dream, and the dick hands. I laughed. That’s unusual. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Ro's avatar
Sep 15Edited

Great piece! Expresses perfectly so many of my worries.

I don't completely agree on the diagnosis of Oppenheimer. I think what they chose was tunnel vision, not spectacle. The US thought Germany was going to build the bomb. Oppenheimer wasn't being irrational to think they were right. The US military was going to build the bomb anyway (it was a problem that somebody was going to eventually figure out).

This didn't make it any less of a terrible thing to do. He should never have done it. None of them should have. And they never, ever should have USED it. That doubles the crime. But it does seem like a tunnel-vision problem--seeing it as a practical problem. They didn't even know it was going to be a spectacle. There are people who would not have been capable of seeing the larger picture --but Oppenheimer was certainly not one of those people. He knew what he was doing. I guess that makes it worse.

Even the German physicists were thinking 'how could they do something this immoral?' People who worked on that thought it. But they compartmentalized. This is how people do many of the terrible things they do.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts